West Virginia gay marriage ban voted down in House.My thoughts are as follows, not just with West Virginia, but with all states in similar situations...
-Gay marriage is currently illegal in West Virginia. Why make a law banning something that's already illegal and already strictly regulated by the government?
-There are two ways that gay marriage could become legal in states like West Virginia-
1) they pass a law/have a state supreme court decision allowing same sex couples to marry
2) there is some sort of federal action legalizing gay marriage, such as:
A) an amendment is passed legalizing gay marriage
B) a supreme court case finds that denying marriage status to same sex couples is unconstitutional
C) an amendment is passed repealing DOMA
Admittedly, the likelihood of any of these happening in the near future is, at best, highly questionable.
Only the third option has any possibility of meriting the need for a state amendment banning gay marriage, but even repealing DOMA doesn't lead to the logic "pro-gay marriage unless proven otherwise by constitutional amendment."
I'm trying to come up with a good simile for this, but I can't think of one that fits exactly.
I'm also fairly certain there's a gaping hole in my logic, but I clearly can't discern what that is right now either. I look forward to your thoughts.